The leaves are falling and temperatures are dropping, which can only mean one thing—holiday gifting season is upon us! Here are our picks for everyone on your list, from your trendiest, food-loving pals to your furry friends! Check out our curated suggestions below!
For the Always On-Trend
Awards and Accolades
While all our recipes are winners in our minds, we are always honored when culinary experts agree! Several of our handcrafted nut butters have received recent acclaim and awards from internationally renowned organizations and publications, like:
-
Vanilla Latte Almond Butter (hailed by The Kitchn as a “Delicious Spread for Breakfast AND Dessert”)
-
Carrot Cake Almond & Walnut Butter (2025 “Best in Taste” Grand Champion, NC Specialty Food Association)
-
Maple Cinnamon Peanut & Pecan Butter (2025 “Best in Taste” Winner, NC Specialty Food Association)
-
Linzer Cookie Cashew & Almond Butter (one of Bon Appétit’s Favorite Nut Butters of 2025)
-
Vanilla Caramel Almond & Cashew Butter (Sofi Award Winner - Best New Product, Specialty Food Association)
For the Gifting Grand Champ
Custom Bundles
Want your gift to be crowned a winner this holiday season? Gift a Custom Build-A-Bundle! Choose a combination of six or 12 recipes (even Wag Butter) in 13oz or 3oz mini jars to stuff stockings or gift a curated restock to your favorite nut butter-loving friends!
Group Gifting
With Group Gifting, send curated gift sets to up to 50 recipients in one seamless transaction. Perhaps best of all, Group Gifting lets you get ahead of your holiday to-do list by offering scheduled gift shipping, up to eight weeks in advance. Don’t have everyone’s address or want to offer a choose-your-own gift adventure? You can also send e-gifts, which allow your recipients to get their gift on their schedule.
For Those Who Can Never Choose a Favorite
Mini 3oz. Variety 4-Pack
Our 3oz Variety Packs are perfect for the person who loves to try a little bit of everything (or who keeps forgetting to give you a holiday wish list). Each set includes four mini 3oz (TSA-approved!) jars of some of our favorite innovative nut butter recipes. With five varieties to choose from, including Winter Mix (shown above), Peanut, Almond, Classic Combo, and Tropical Vegan, you'll be sure to find one they'll love!
Bar Variety Pack
Can’t decide on a single nut butter bar recipe to give your favorite serial snacker? With a 12-bar Variety Pack, your giftee gets three bars, each, of our four beloved peanut butter-based recipes: Figgy Chai, Apricot Pepita, Cranberry Cashew, and Cherry Chocolate.
For the Devoted Foodie
Nut Butter Subscriptions
What’s better than one jar of nut butter? Monthly nut butter delivered right to your door! Indulge your favorite foodies with a tasty gift that keeps giving year-round. For a sweet surprise, our Roaster’s Choice Subscription delivers a different, innovative seasonal nut butter every month, handpicked by our team!
For those who know what they like but still appreciate a little love in the mail each month, treat them to regular deliveries of their favorite recipe. All our subscriptions are available in 3, 6, 12-shipment, or ongoing durations for a delightful delivery they’ll look forward to, month after month.
AB&J or PB&J Subscriptions
Delight anyone on your list with regular shipments of our featured AB&J or PB&J pairings! Each subscription includes a jar of small-batch Featured Jam paired with a recommended 13oz jar of fresh-roasted almond or peanut butter every two months, starting in January!
Bar Subscriptions
Keep the busy people in your life stocked with wholesome, on-the-go nutrition – a nut butter bar subscription delivered to their door every month! With four delicious, protein-packed recipes to choose from (or a variety pack!), there’s a bar for every person and preference!
For the Nut Butter Activist
Staff Picks Trio (supporting Zero Foodprint)
Our Fall/Winter Staff Picks Trio is curated by our Logistics Lead, Katie! This Trio contains one 13oz jar and six bars, respectively, of Figgy Chai Peanut Butter Bars, Maple Cinnamon Peanut & Pecan Butter, and Vanilla Latte Almond Butter.
From Nov. 17 through December 31, $1 from each Staff Picks Trio sold will be donated to Zero Foodprint, a 501(c)(3) organization working to reduce emissions and increase regenerative farming practices to better our food systems for generations to come.
Lum Lum Thai Curry Peanut & Cashew Butter (supporting Carolina Tiger Rescue)
In Northern Thailand, “lum lum” is slang for “delicious,” and we think it’s the perfect descriptor for this special nut butter (a 2024 Good Food Award winner)! With savory lemongrass and curry notes that give way to a warming spice on the back palate, Lum Lum Thai Curry is perfect for weaving into your favorite recipes, like peanut sauces and veggie stir fries, or just for enjoying a spoonful anytime you need to wake up your taste buds.
Plus, this nut butter saves tigers! Proceeds from each jar sold support Carolina Tiger Rescue and our shared efforts to fight against environmental devastation and habitat loss caused by palm oil production.
For that Stylish Someone
Big Spoon Roasters Merch
Stickers, hats, and shirts, oh my! Our merch page has lots of options for those proud nut butter (and Big Spoon) lovers.
Ware Ware Studio PB & Toast Tumbler
Our local friend Katy of Ware Ware Studio hand-made these incredible ceramic tumblers exclusively for Big Spoon Roasters! Featuring the cutest sticker-inspired nut butter-and-toast decals, these are ideal for your morning coffee, breakfast yogurt bowl, scoops of ice cream, and any snack or sip in between. Plus, they’re dishwasher and microwave-safe to fit right into your routine.
For the Sweet Treat Lover
Holiday Trio
Whether for a post-dinner snack, a little goodness to start your day, or something to get you through the midday slump, we believe in the power of a little sweet treat. For those craving a satisfying, sweet snack with nourishing ingredients, look no further than this year‘s Holiday Trio, featuring three low-glycemic recipes inspired by our favorite seasonal confections!
For the Coffee Shop Connoisseur
Vanilla Latte Almond Butter
Your favorite coffee order got a makeover! Our Vanilla Latte Almond Butter combines the sweetness of maple and real vanilla bean with the punch of Madcap Coffee’s “Eureka” espresso to make a delicious almond butter that coffee lovers in your life will love on toast, paired with fruit, or just by the spoonful!
Chai Spice Peanut & Almond Butter
Not a coffee fan? We have something for you, too! Featuring a traditional Masala Chai blend of cardamom, cloves, ginger, cinnamon, vanilla, and black pepper, Chai Spice contains a bright, complex burst of flavor in every spoonful. Don’t just take our word for it – Bon Appétit loves it just as much as we do!
For the Pawesome Pups
Wag Butter and Wag Gift Sets
Don't forget the furry friends in your life this holiday season! Treat them to the best of the best with our line of Wag Butter – Peanut Butter for Dogs (Bon Appétit approved!).
Created with the same world-class ingredients as our “human” nut butters, Wag Butter is a complete source of pup protein, without sugar and salt, and with added dog “superfoods” to nourish your good boys and girls from the inside out! With mini (3oz) & full-size (13oz) options, and three recipes, to choose from—NEW Vanilla Tater, Banana Flax, and Pumpkin Spice—there’s plenty of “pawsibilities!”
For an enriching treat time, pair Wag Butter with a licking mat or West Paw treat toy, all found in our Wag Shop!
