'Tis the season of gifting, and if you're stuck on what to get the special people in your life, we've got you covered. Below, find our picks for everyone on your list—after all, nothing shows you care like delicious, handcrafted food.
For the Culinary Connoisseur
Lum Lum Thai Curry Peanut & Cashew Butter
Lum Lum Thai Curry Peanut & Cashew Butter is one of our most innovative nut butters, with savory, lemongrass, and curry notes that give way to a warming spice on the back palate. It's perfect for weaving into your favorite recipes, like peanut sauces and veggie stir fries, or just for enjoying a spoonful anytime you need to wake up your taste buds. As a bonus, this nut butter does (and tastes) GOOD - proceeds from each jar sold support Carolina Tiger Rescue.
For the Holiday Cheermeister
Gingerbread Crunch Almond & Pecan Butter
We all have a friend who’s decking the halls the minute the clock hits November 1, so treat them to a taste of their favorite season. One of our most popular Limited Batches ever, Gingerbread Crunch Almond & Pecan Butter is spreadable coziness and the tastiest way to let your holiday-loving friends know you love them.
For the Self-Proclaimed Foodie
Mini 3-oz Sampling Set
Our 3oz Variety Packs are perfect for the person who loves to try a little bit of everything. These sets include four mini (TSA-approved!) jars of some of our favorite, innovative nut butter recipes. With 5 curated varieties to choose from (including Winter Mix, Peanut, Almond, Classic Combo, and Tropical Vegan), you'll be sure to find one they'll love.
For Your Furry Friends
Wag Butter – Peanut Butter for Dogs
Don’t forget the pups this holiday season! Treat them to the best of the best with our line of Wag Butter – Peanut Butter for Dogs! Even Bon Appetit loves Wag Butter! Created with the same highest-quality ingredients as our “human” nut butters, Wag Butter is a complete source of pup protein, without sugar and salt, and with added dog “superfoods” to nourish them from the inside out! With three recipes to choose from—Coconut Chia, Banana Flax, and Pumpkin Spice—there’s something for every good boy and girl on your list. Save a trip to the pet store and grab a toy to go alongside—all toys on our Wag Shop are from likeminded producers and made with peanut butter-spreading in mind.
For the Long-Distance Loves
Monthly Nut Butter Subscription
A one-time gift is great, but what’s even better? A monthly treat, delivered right to your door! For the true lover of surprises, our Roaster’s Choice Subscription delivers a different seasonal nut butter every month, chosen by our team! Or, for those who know their faves but still appreciate a little love in the mail each month, send them their favorite recipe—all our subscriptions are available in 3, 6, 12-month, or ongoing durations for a surprise and delight moment even after the holiday season has passed.
For the One Always On-the-Go
Nut Butter Bar Subscription
Our nut butter bars are everything you want in an energy bar—complete protein, delicious flavor profile, and real, crave-worthy food—and nothing you don’t. No artificial colors, flavors, or chemicals here! They make the perfect snack on the go, or fuel for whatever adventure life throws your way. Keep your busy bestie stocked with a subscription that comes to their door every month—with six recipes to choose from (or a variety pack!), there’s one for every taste.
For the Host with the Most
Nut Butter Trio
Host gifts can be forgettable, but this one will secure your name on the invite list for seasons to come. Our Seasonal Nut Butter Trio contains three of our coziest, warming nut butters for the coziest taste of the season, all pre-packaged in a sweet gift box to create a tasty and chic gift for your favorite host or hostess. Not feeling the seasonal flavor profiles? We have four other curated Trios to choose from, from Vegan to Holiday and Staff Picks, chosen by one of our team members!
For the Nut Butter Loyalist
Big Spoon Roasters Merch
Let them rep their nut butter love with our line of merch! From lunch coolers to beach blankets, we have some stylish yet durable (and of course, sustainable) ways to show off their favorite snack.
For the Always Informed
photo by Emma Fishman
Award-Winners
Who needs to research when you can lean on culinary experts? Several of our nut butters and bars have received immense acclaim and awards from internationally renowned organizations and publications, like:
- Pistachio Crunch Almond Butter (Good Food Award – 2023)
- Vanilla Caramel Almond & Cashew Butter (Specialty Food Association Sofi Award for Best New Product – 2023)
- Lum Lum Thai Curry Peanut & Cashew Butter (Good Food Award – 2024)
- Banana Flax Wag Butter (Bon Appetit Highly Recommend)
- Chai Spice Peanut & Almond Butter (Bon Appetit Highly Recommend)
- Carrot Cake Almond & Walnut Butter (The Kitchn’s “Pantry Staple I Can’t Stop Eating”)
- Sweet Heat (Southern Living Food Award - 2017)
- Almond Butter with Wildflower Honey (Southern Living Food Award - 2016)
- Lemon Cookie Cashew Butter (NC Specialty Food Association, Gold – 2023)
For The One Who Has Everything
Custom 2-Pack Gift Box
Take the guesswork out of gifting with our Custom 2-Pack Gift Box! It’s beautifully packaged with 5 different combos of bestselling nut butters to choose from, making the perfect gift—and new favorite snack—for the recipient who seems to have everything.
For The One Who Loves to Choose
Gift Card
Give the gift of choice with our Virtual Gift Card! It gets sent directly to your recipient’s email so they can pick the perfect thing for them, based on mood, season, or any other preference. Bonus—this works perfectly as a little last-minute gift—it instantly delivers with no wrapping needed.